In order to gain the market research, which will allow us to decide on what form ident appeals most to the target audience. To do this we gathered a collection of ideas from a similar channel which appeals to the same type of audience for us and showed them to the audience. The idents that were chosen were from BBC Three and from different suites. The reason for doing this is to see what key components should be left out or included for the ident I will create.
The first video that was chosen is from BBC Three between 2003 and 2008. This suite of idents showed characters which were slugs standing in front of a large "Three".
The second suite went for a more random approach which was colourful and lively. This ident went from 2008 to 2013
Th final ident revolves around blocks rotating and moving around to create pictures and the logo. This is the newest ident.
After showing the focus group the idents a few times we then proceeded to asking them questions about what they just saw.
The first question that was asked was "Which one did you prefer and why?" Asking this question will allow us to pinpoint the type of ident people enjoyed the most so that we could avoid the less popular ones and try to include the parts that people liked. The following are the answers that were given:
a) I preferred ident 3 because of the interchanging people.
b) I preferred ident 2 as it was more interesting than the other idents.
c) I preferred ident 2 because there was more to look at onscreen.
d) I preferred ident 1 as it was simple and easy to remember.
e) I preferred ident 1 as it had humour and was different to conventional idents.
f) I preferred ident 2 because I enjoyed watching the dancing people.
From looking at these answers, the second ident was the favourite. The things that people liked most about it was that it was more interesting and there was a lot on the screen to look at. This means that when making the ident it would be best to include movement and make it interesting. This can either be done by suspense or including lots of things.
The second question that was asked was "What was the main thing that caught your attention?" This was to pinpoint specifics that they liked such as colour, sound and movement. The answer to this were:
a) Bright colours and fast paced
b) The little animated people
c) The colours were vivid
d) Little creature stood out
e) The red blob on blue background
f) Neon colour, lots happening
By analysing these answers the two main things that people liked were the bright colours and contrast between the colours. This means that including a contrast along with bright colours would be ideal in order to gain the best effect on getting the audiences attention.
The next question that we asked the audience about the idents was "Which was your least favourite and why?" Avoiding things that make an ident non appealing is just as important as finding what works best and this is why we asked this question. The answers are as follows:
a) My least favourite was ident 1, I thought that it was a boring ident
b) My least favourite was ident 1, It had no real purpose or meaning behind it
c) My least favourite was ident 3, I couldn't tell what was supposed to be going on
d) My least favourite was ident 3, I don't like the way the images moved around
e) My least favourite was ident 2, I didn't dislike it, it just wasn't my favourite
f) My least favourite was ident 1, It was plain and simple, not entertaining
The least favourite overall was the first ident which was the slug talking and the reasons for this was that it was boring because it was simple and wasn't entertaining. By looking at answers to the other questions also the reason for it being bring was that there wasn't any movement or bright colours.
"Did the sound on the idents match what was happening?" was the fourth question which was asked and the reason for asking this is that sound can be a very important factor in how much the ident will draw the attention of the audience. Although this is a difficult question to be able to interpret into our own idents if will allow us to reference between the least favourite and see whether the sound can be linked to why it was their least favourite. Answers this question were:
a) I think that the sound went well with all of them
b) I think the sound matched although ident 1 should have had sound
c) The sound in ident 2 matched what was happening
d) I thought that they all sounded good
e) Ident 1 was boring and could have had sound
f) The sound in ident 3 matched better than the others
Ident one once again came up being the worst and this was because they thought the ident should have had background music and more sound which made it boring. This shows how in order to make my ident as good as it could be is to include music that will correlate with the movement. This means that if the movement was fast paced then the sound would have to correlate with this.